Trick plays are great when they work. They’re fun to watch, and when they lead to a touchdown or other big play, they’re a thing of beauty.
When trick plays don’t work, they can still be fun to watch, even if they’re ugly. The Clemson Tigers tried a trick play Saturday that ended with disastrous results, and led to a South Carolina Gamecocks touchdown.
On a second-quarter kickoff return, Tigers returner Will Shipley received the kick, ran up the field, and met a group of four teammates in a huddle. As defenders closed in, the four Tigers all broke in different directions, with running back Phil Mafah taking the ball and running toward the right sideline.
The play worked, to a certain degree. Mafah gained 19 yards before Gamecocks players surrounded him. Then disaster struck — he fumbled the ball, and South Carolina recovered.
Clemson got a bit too cute for their own good on this kick return. pic.twitter.com/sYyKnDnUIU
— The Comeback (@thecomeback) November 26, 2022
A replay of the trick play somehow makes it look even worse. Mafah even appears to be trying to pass the ball to a teammate.
Replay of Clemson's curious kick return makes it look ever worse. pic.twitter.com/82dfAynaed
— The Comeback (@thecomeback) November 26, 2022
Four plays later, the Gamecocks scored a touchdown to bring the score to 16-14.
Fans weren’t sure what they had just witnessed.
“The trick part was successful to a degree. The dude just fumbled inexplicably without anyone making contact on the ball,” tweeted Javi Perez.
This. The trick part was successful to a degree. The dude just fumbled inexplicably without anyone making contact on the ball.
— Javi Perez (@JaviPerez7AM) November 26, 2022
does it? it was a pretty awesome play. Returner just happened to fumble
— MachineGunTrey (@Kjgans) November 26, 2022
When I say I almost jumped through this damn tv!
— Why Not …. ⏳ (@_Shoottaa) November 26, 2022