Vince Ferragamo and Johnny Manziel.

Johnny Manziel’s first start in the Canadian Football League did not go as planned. After a July 22 trade from the Hamilton Tiger-Cats to the then 1-4 Montreal Alouettes gave him the chance to play, Manziel (seen at right above) received his first start Friday, and it came against his former team in Hamilton. But the Tiger-Cats scored on their first drive, Manziel threw an interception on his first passing attempt, and he followed that up with three more picks by the half, a point by which Montreal trailed 38-3.

Manziel finished with 11 completions on 20 attempts for 104 yards with those four picks before he was replaced by Vernon Adams Jr. (who previously was seen complaining about fans’ “We Want Johnny” chants during the Alouettes’ last game, and led Montreal’s only touchdown-drive here late in garbage time). Meanwhile, Hamilton quarterback Jeremiah Masoli, the man Manziel couldn’t beat out with the Tiger-Cats, threw for 300 yards and two touchdowns (albeit with two interceptions) before being pulled in the fourth quarter. And the Alouettes wound up losing 50-11. Here’s a compilation of Manziel’s picks:

Interestingly enough, this had plenty of similarities to another blowout of a Montreal team with a highly-hyped American quarterback. That would be Vince Ferragamo, who led the Los Angeles Rams to a 1980 Super Bowl appearance as a fourth-year player, but only made $52,000 U.S. that year. In an era before NFL free agency, that provided an opportunity for other leagues to swoop in, and Alouettes’ owner Nelson Skalbania signed Ferragamo (as well as first-round NFL picks Keith Gary, David Overstreet and Tom Cousineau, as well as proven NFL receivers Billy “White Shoes” Johnson and James Scott) to a deal reportedly worth $750,000 Canadian (around $600,000 U.S.) per year for four years. But Ferragamo didn’t find a lot of CFL success, and a 58-2 loss in Winnipeg on August 8, 1981 was particularly similar to this one.

Montreal was 1-4 heading into that game, but had some hype (with Ferragamo on the cover of Sports Illustrated two weeks before, as seen at left above). Meanwhile the Bombers were 4-1, but were facing questions about how they’d do against a squad with so many well-paid American stars. Well, it turns out that it went even worse for the Alouettes than Manziel’s starting debut, with Ferragamo completing just 11 of 29 passes for 97 yards with four interceptions and Montreal losing 58-2. Mike Sawatsky of The Winnipeg Free Press has a new oral history of that game that’s just perfectly timed, and some of the comments seem relevant to Manziel’s situation:

“I thought we were good because we had some talented people, but you know, just because you see these great people on paper, great players, it doesn’t mean it’s going to mesh,” says Gerry Dattilio, Ferragamo’s backup that day.

“Sometimes it’s better to have a bunch of no-names playing for one cause instead of a bunch of superstars. We had a lot of superstars on paper, there’s no way it should’ve been anything but the Grey Cup… It was a wipeout that year but we made the playoffs that year, believe it or not, because the East was so terrible.”

…”Yeah, I remember the Winnipeg game,” says Vince Ferragamo, almost 37 years later.

“Dieter Brock… it was 58-2! All I can remember was that cannon going off (after every Winnipeg scoring play). I sat there on the sidelines, thinking to myself, ‘What play can I call to get two yards? I’ve gotta be able to call a play that can get me at least two yards. Gosh, what are we gonna do?’ “

That sounds a lot like what happened to Manziel Friday, except even worse; Manziel at least was able to pull off a couple of promising plays. And of course, things may not end as poorly for Manziel in the CFL as they did for Ferragamo; Ferragamo completed just 175 of 342 passes (51.2%) for 2175 yards, with seven touchdown passes and 25 interceptions, and while Montreal still made the playoffs despite a 3-13 record (they were better than the 2-14 Toronto Argonauts), they lost 20-16 to Ottawa in the East semifinals. Alouettes’ owner Nelson Skalbania (who would later be infamous for buying and selling the Edmonton Oilers, moving the Atlanta Flames, buying the B.C. Lions and having them forced into receivership, and going to jail in 1998 for using an investor’s money to cover his real-estate firm’s debts) reportedly lost $2 million that year, and the team went bankrupt (they were replaced by a separate short-lived Montreal Concordes franchise; the current Alouettes are a new team that came back to Montreal in 1996, moving from Baltimore after the collapse of CFL USA), so Ferragamo never even got all his money. (He was smart to get some of it up front, though, and he did wind up going back to the NFL in 1982 and having more success there.) However things go for Manziel, at least a full-on team bankruptcy seems unlikely.

And it’s quite possible that Manziel could wind up being fine in the CFL. He’s only been with the team for a couple of weeks, and he needs time to learn their playbook and adjust to their personnel. The Alouettes also had lots of issues before Manziel came along; they were 1-4 with all sorts of personnel issues before the trade, so this isn’t all on him. And he could still improve significantly. But Ferragamo is one of the many examples over the years that big-name quarterbacks don’t always work out in the CFL, and that you can’t just walk in and expect to dominate the league. Hopefully Manziel’s stint north of the border will end better than Ferragamo’s did, but his beginnings were certainly similar.

[The Winnipeg Free Press]

About Andrew Bucholtz

Andrew Bucholtz has been covering sports media for Awful Announcing since 2012. He is also a staff writer for The Comeback. His previous work includes time at Yahoo! Sports Canada and Black Press.