SAN FRANCISCO, CA – MAY 16: Christian Arroyo #22 and Mac Williamson #51 of the San Francisco Giants fail to catch a fly ball hit by Justin Turner #10 of the Los Angeles Dodgers at AT&T Park on May 16, 2017 in San Francisco, California. (Photo by Lachlan Cunningham/Getty Images)

The National League has been considered inferior to the American League for several decades now. That’s reflected at the All-Star Game, where the AL has won four in a row, 16 of the past 20 and 22 of the past 26. And, more importantly, it’s reflected in interleague play, where the AL has beaten the NL every single year since 2003.

But this year, the NL could be hitting a new low. After the Athletics’ win over the Nationals on Saturday, the NL is currently 41-61 against the AL, for a .402 winning percentage that, if it lasts all season, would be the second worst in the 22-year history of interleague play. Relative to the AL, the NL is as bad as it has ever been.


Beyond just being flat-out worse than the AL, the NL is in many ways less interesting. The best player in baseball (Mike Trout) plays in the AL. So does the MLB home run leader and 2017 breakout star (Aaron Judge). Despite the perception that the NL has the game’s best pitchers, the AL actually has baseball top three ERA leaders this season. Even so, the AL has scored more runs and whacked more homers than the NL. MLB’s best team by record and run differential (the Astros) plays in the AL.

The NL standings are fairly uninspiring as well. Somehow, the Senior Circuit has only six teams at or above .500. Unless the surprising Rockies, Diamondbacks and Brewers all keep up their hot starts, the NL wild-card could be remarkably mediocre. We can assume the Nationals, Dodgers and Cubs (yes, the Cubs will be OK) will make the playoffs, but after that the NL is a league full of question marks.

Entering the year, the lead NL wild card favorites were the Mets, Giants, Pirates and Cardinals. Well the Mets have been destroyed by injuries, the Giants and Pirates are in last place and the Cardinals are under .500. No one expected the NL playoff picture to be particularly exciting, but it’s looking even duller than we could have imagined.

Basically, the AL is dominating interleague play, carrying a disproportionate number of the game’s best storylines and shaping up for a far better playoff race than the NL.

And the NL? At least it’s got Bryce Harper.



About Alex Putterman

Alex is a writer and editor for The Comeback and Awful Announcing. He has written for The Atlantic, VICE Sports,, and more. He is a proud alum of Northwestern University and The Daily Northwestern. You can find him on Twitter @AlexPutterman.

1 thought on “The National League is really bad this year—and also kind of boring

  1. None of the points made in your argument are very compelling to me. Besides, look at how boring the A.L. is in 2018. It’s a snooze fest. We have 1/3 of the whole season left to play and we already know with extremely high probability every one of the teams that will make the playoffs, with the exception of finding out which team will play the Yankees in the wild card game. The NL is playing competitive games that matter. As of this writing, there are 9 teams that still look to be competing for 5 spots in the postseason (4 spots if you don’t count the WC game).

Comments are closed.