College football is rife with “what ifs” and turning points. It’s hard to find a bigger one than Penn State’s blocked field goal against Ohio State in 2016. It was one play, it was a fluke, and it changed the perception of the Penn State program under James Franklin.

Franklin seemed to be on the hot seat entering the season. Penn State went 6-10 in B1G conference play during his first two seasons. Franklin fired offensive coordinator John Donovan that offseason. Longtime Franklin assistants Herb Hand (offensive line) and Bob Shoop (defensive coordinator) left for SEC jobs. The best argument for keeping Franklin off the hot seat was Penn State’s roster issues from NCAA sanctions.

His seat still felt rather warm in October. Franklin lost his competitive non-conference game against Pitt. Michigan obliterated the Nittany Lions by 39 points in Ann Arbor. Penn State did rebound to beat Minnesota in overtime. But that was the team’s best conference win (up to that point) under Franklin. It was the first conference win that was not against Indiana, Maryland, Rutgers, or Illinois.

Then came the Ohio State game on Oct. 22. Even into the fourth quarter, it looked like a perfunctory Buckeye win. The Ohio State offense, not exactly rolling at that point, had done enough to get a 21-7 lead. The Nittany Lions scrabbled their way back with a touchdown and a field goal to make it 21-17.

Ohio State attempted a field goal to regain a seven-point lead. Penn State blocked the attempt. It bounced well to the right, to the Nittany Lions’ edge rusher Grant Haley who had a clear path to the end zone and a 24-21 Penn State lead.

The play was not 100 percent fluky. But most of it was. Blocking a field goal requires some skill. Yet it also calls for an equal part or more in execution errors by the kicking team. Haley did a great job returning the ball. However, it was fortune that dropped the ball into his path instead of the ground.

Fortunate or not, the play happened. It earned Penn State the big upset. That upset morphed into much more when it became apparent Penn State had a route to winning the B1G East.

The Nittany Lions’ remaining schedule was soft. PSU had road trips to Purdue, Indiana, and Rutgers. They faced a horrible Michigan State team and a mediocre Iowa one at home. Penn State ending up 7-1 in the Big Ten, with a head-to-head against Ohio State, was probable.

Winning out, Penn State needed Michigan to finish 6-2. The Wolverines had the head-to-head win over Penn State. A three-way tie between OSU, PSU, and Michigan would have sent Ohio State to the title game. The Hawkeyes obliged with a November surprise. Then Michigan lost a narrow game in Columbus. Penn State won the division.

The Nittany Lions came from behind to beat Wisconsin and won the conference, adding a second quality win (and first that didn’t come on a blocked field goal). Penn State had one good regular season win, on a fluky play. But they were Big Ten champions. Had Clemson or Washington faltered in their title games, Penn State probably would have gone to the playoff ahead of Michigan, the team that beat them by 39.

Winning the Big Ten created an enormous perceptual shift. Franklin’s tenure, muddled well into October, became a success story, a natural outgrowth of his three-year rebuilding process. Penn State battling USC in an epic Rose Bowl (or blowing a two-touchdown fourth quarter lead) only added to the respect. College football writers now wonder whether Jim Harbaugh can follow Franklin’s lead.

That opening, again caused by a fluke play, could pay even further dividends for Franklin. He is an active recruiter and Penn State is an “it” program, at least for now. Penn State has the nation’s No. 3 overall class on board for 2018, per the 247 Composite and four Top 100 overall recruits.

The Penn State resurgence narrative does not have the firmest foundation. Everything comes down to one fluke play. But, with confidence building in Happy Valley and recruits coming in, the origin may not matter.

About Ty Duffy

Ty is a freelance writer/editor based outside Detroit. He's a Michigan Man. He enjoys dogs, whiskey, yoga, and composing pithy career summaries. Contact him at

1 thought on “Perception of James Franklin and Penn State changed quickly; one play made the difference

  1. the bitterness is so transparent in this article. jim harbaugh inherited a full roster loaded with experienced upperclassman while james franklin inherited a roster decimated due to scholarship limits. and yet, franklin goes 9-1 against conference opponents and wins the big ten title. yet this successful season should be dismissed as a fluke b/c of one lucky bounce in one play against a good team? at the same time, loaded michigan finishes third with a loss to “mediocre” iowa that you claim was part of psu’s soft schedule?

    i’m going to suggest something that might seem crazy to you but is reality to most objective observers….penn state had a really young roster last year that struggled early in the season due to inexperience. but the coaches developed the talented young players and they gained confidence and were a better team at the end of the season. crazy thought, right?

Comments are closed.