Jan 1, 2019; South Bend, IN, USA; A general view as players shake hands after the third period in the 2019 Winter Classic hockey game between the Chicago Blackhawks and the Boston Bruins at Notre Dame Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Matt Cashore-USA TODAY Sports

The 2019 NHL Winter Classic was a memorable contest between the Chicago Blackhawks and the Boston Bruins at Notre Dame Stadium. While the headlines were dominated by food running out at the stadium and the Blackhawks losing yet another outdoor game, the league enjoyed a slight uptick in television ratings with their best mark in four years.

But something is missing.

Once upon a time, the Winter Classic was a must-see event. Serious, casual and even non-hockey fans made a point to watch the NHL play outdoors. The Winter Classic felt like something special and unique. Unfortunately, that’s no longer the case. The increase in outdoor games, the repeated use of the same teams and a lack of innovation has watered down the Winter Classic experience.

Even with their best ratings mark in four years, the league is still attempting to recover from a steep drop that started years ago.

What can the NHL do to right the ship? How can they make the Winter Classic their marquee event once again?

Feature Different Teams

The easiest and quickest solution is to feature different teams as soon as possible. As fun as it has been to watch the Blackhawks lose Winter Classic after Winter Classic (they’re now 0-4), it’s time for something different. The NHL is already moving in that direction by calling on the Dallas Stars for the next Winter Classic, but they need to avoid falling back and once again calling on their usual participants. Through 11 Winter Classic games, eight teams have participated two or more times. That’s absurd.

Meanwhile, ratings have proved to be decent in markets beyond the stereotypical ones. Check out Las Vegas.

NBC will want a team from a major market in the hopes of big ratings, but wouldn’t it make more sense to grow the overall base by featuring teams people haven’t seen ad nauseam?

Unique Locations

This is another area where the NHL is improving, but why not bring the game outside in some of the most unique locations in North America? The league has proved that they can pull off outdoor games in warmer climates. That should open up some great venues (imagine a puck making it into McCovey Cove at AT&T Park) where the venue itself is worth talking about. CenturyLink Field would be another great venue that the NHL could explore once the new Seattle franchise debuts.

Beyond those, the NHL could throw a curve ball and try something totally off the wall. Imagine a game in Central Park or in an outdoor location that doesn’t fit the traditional stadium mold. Now those would get people talking. The idea is more than feasible, but the desire for the largest crowd possible may overwhelm the most innovative ideas.

Creativity could and should be used instead of falling back on what’s the easiest, largest or most convenient stadium.

New Technology

No, we’re not advocating for the return of the glowing puck. That ship has thankfully sailed. We are asking for the NHL and for its broadcast partners to innovate for the Winter Classic. Beyond a couple new camera views, one being the overhead view which is often ridiculed for being a bit nauseating, the broadcast doesn’t do enough to go outside the box.

The idea of increased technology is an area the NHL is moving towards in the form of puck and player-tracking technology. But why not roll out one or two new features for the Winter Classic? Consider it a testing ground in a real-game scenario that is already taken with a grain of salt thanks to the outdoor conditions.

The NHL and NBC should roll out all the stops for what is described as the league’s marquee event. Jeremy Roenick dancing isn’t going to cut it.

Embrace Themes

The Winter Classic already features vintage uniforms by the teams competing. But why stop there? Why not make one Winter Classic the one that celebrates 1960s hockey? Or one that celebrates the ’80s? Go all the way with the idea with the broadcast embracing the technology and looks of the day. Or try some other sort of theme. The NHL loves to sell rivalries and history, but it rarely goes all the way in execution.

This is another area where creativity could go a long way in getting viewers to tune in. Avoid being too cheesy and you may have a memorable broadcast.

Cut the Stadium Series

The NHL saw a very good thing in the Winter Classic. They also saw a very profitable thing. That led to the creation of the Stadium Series and additional outdoor games beyond the Winter Classic. As more and more outdoor games were played, the Winter Classic started feeling like less of a special event and more of a “been there, done that” event.

The league needs to avoid the temptation of putting on more than one or two outdoor games each year. The Winter Classic in the United States and the Heritage Classic in Canada should be where the outdoor games begin and end each calendar year.

Stop watering down what was one of your best ideas.

Improve the Entertainment

Ultimately, the Winter Classic should focus on hockey and the game being played. But, if the league is going to try and offer some live entertainment, they could at least book acts that resonate with modern audiences. Weezer played the 2019 edition, which admittedly could have been worse. However, previous choices such as Nate Reuss, American Authors and the Goo Goo Dolls suggested that the NHL might be stuck in a different musical era.

The NHL has been historically dreadful when it comes to picking entertainment. Though things are improving, they still have a long way to go.

Acknowledge Weaknesses

The NHL has routinely sold the Winter Classic as the end-all, be-all hockey event. That doesn’t work out too well when similar versions of the idea are held about a month later and then when the same idea is pushed during the playoffs. The league needs to know what the Winter Classic is and what it isn’t.

The Winter Classic is an amazing experience for hockey fans and non-hockey fans to experience in person. And that may be the key to all of this. The event is the best when it’s viewed by those in attendance. Watching on TV can edge on annoying if you’re just hoping to see a hockey game without all of the talking heads, hype and unnecessary broadcast segments.

Market the game as it is and start trying to fix what isn’t working. There’s no use pretending the Winter Classic is a bulletproof idea when key metrics suggest there’s room to improve.

About David Rogers

Editor for The Comeback and Contributing Editor for Awful Announcing. Lover of hockey, soccer and all things pop culture.

6 thoughts on “How can the NHL make the Winter Classic more exciting?

  1. Get the Winter Classic deeper into the actual winter, so the game means more.

    Get off the TV schedule against Bowl Games.


  2. Bring the game to Jacksonville. Yes, Jacksonville. Florida.

    We have a loyal hockey fan base here for our ECHL team, the Icemen. We have a stadium, a coliseum and a baseball park within walking distance of each other and all three could be used for a weekend festival around the game.

    Next to the stadium, the Jaguars’ owner built a 5000-plus-seat amphitheater that could host that concert attached to the game. We have the infrastructure to put up and maintain the rink, even if the local weather warms up a bit (and our winters are chilly here, just without the inconvenience of blizzards and ice and below-freezing temps). Jacksonville is easy to fly into for out-of-town fans. Actually, it’s pretty easy to get here no matter how you travel.

    Put the game in TIAA Bank Field in February, after the Super Bowl, before the NFL Combine and before pitchers/catchers report for spring training. That’s a dead time and would help attract a great crowd.

    Other than that, I agree with everything else you said. Great piece.

  3. Get rid of the horrible NBC talkers. That’s all they do is talk about things, not hockey. I muted my TV for at least 10 minutes into the first period because of all the non-hockey “talk”. Show the game not the cool camera angles that prevent you from watching the game.

    1. sports are better watched using the mute volume control on your remote. Do you really need the volume? …..Unless you are watching with a non-sports fan. I would suggest playing music while watching. Start out with a little Greta van Fleet and let your Spotify take you from there. Been watching sports this way for some time. I don’t miss the announcers.

  4. For next year, I would have the Stars face the LA Kings, who have NOT been in the Winter Classic AND like the Stars are an original 1967 expansion franchise. Having LA in the game would be good.

    I would look at Denver (maybe play such a game in Boulder at the University of Colorado’s Stadium if Coors Field is unavailable) or as suggested A T & T Park in San Francisco (though you can get heavy rain there in January, and where it can be up to A FOOT of rain at one time).

  5. I’ve often thought that the All- Star game should be the winter classic. It’s deeper in the winter, the bowl games are over, and playoff football isn’t going on. Plus the stars that carry the sport will draw in fringe fans.

Comments are closed.