WWE world questions controversial WrestleMania finish

Roman Reigns has held the WWE Universal Championship since August, 2020. He’s been WWE’s undisputed champion since winning the WWE Championship on Night 2 of Wrestlemania 38 on April 3, 2022.

Everything seemed aligned for Cody Rhodes, winner of the 2023 Royal Rumble, to beat Reigns in the Main Event of Wrestlemania 39’s Night 2 on Sunday night.

It didn’t happen.

Reigns and Rhodes put on a classic match with interference from Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn on Rhodes’ behalf and Solo Sikoa, The Usos and Paul Heyman for Reigns. In the end, WWE decided to keep the belt on Reigns. 

Thanks to @WWESoloSikoa, @WWERomanReigns RETAINS against @CodyRhodes at #WrestleMania!@HeymanHustle pic.twitter.com/Q1vUPOHokZ

— WWE (@WWE) April 3, 2023

WWE fans didn’t understand the decision to keep Reigns as Universal Champion.

An all-time great Wrestlemania with an all-time baffling, lackluster finish to the main event. I can't imagine WWE is going to get any hotter than Roman-Sami-Cody this weekend. We'll see. I have my doubts. #WrestleMania

— Jim Valley (@JimValley) April 3, 2023

Not only was it the wrong finish, it was a terrible finish. Not very dramatic or well choreographed. Cody took everything Roman could deliver and then he fell to a quick shot from Solo? That's a RAW finish, not a #WrestleMania finish.

— Jim Valley (@JimValley) April 3, 2023

I AM CONFUSED #WrestleMania

— Jack The Jobber (@JackTheJobber) April 3, 2023

If and when Cody Rhodes wins the big one it won’t mean nearly as much as it would have tonight. #WrestleMania

— Scott Fishman (@smFISHMAN) April 3, 2023

That was the wrong call.

— Amanda (@MandaLHuber) April 3, 2023

I guess they wanted to make sure everyone was nice and sober for the drive home. #WrestleMania

— Brian Zane (@zmanbrianzane) April 3, 2023

basically.#WrestleMania pic.twitter.com/mDHUkzjn6R

— Wrestle Ops (@WrestleOps) April 3, 2023

And perhaps more than anything, WWE was light on viable challengers for Reigns before Sunday. Rhodes reappeared in WWE at WrestleMania 38 a year ago, then missed much of the subsequent year recovering from an injury. So, he was still a relatively fresh option.

But going forward, Reigns has defeated nearly all of the WWE’s top names during his run as champion and in many cases, has beaten them multiple times.

So going forward, who challenges Reigns and more pressingly, who will ultimately beat him and when will that be?

This is the MOST flat I've ever been after a #WrestleMania

There was really zero reason for Reigns to retain. Who's going to stop him? The belts are held hostage until god knows when. Massive L.

— Wrestlelamia.com (@wrestlelamia) April 3, 2023

Literally makes no sense. #WrestleMania

You're not waiting for the Rock to take it. You're not waiting for Cody to take it. You're not waiting for Seth to take it, or Brock or Drew.

Only person left pic.twitter.com/4DeyNmQanK

— Wrestlelamia.com (@wrestlelamia) April 3, 2023

Fan interest at subsequent shows will ultimately determine if the right call was made. But it will certainly be a lot harder to sell someone else to challenge (and ultimately defeat) Reigns than it would have been to have Reigns or someone else defeat Rhodes if his time as champion didn’t do good business.

And while there’s something to be said for steering away from expectations, it’s also worth noting that in WWE’s most popular periods, the biggest shows of the year almost always ended with the expected person standing tall. It’s one of the beauties of a sport with predetermined results. The best stories don’t always win in the NFL, MLB, NBA or any other league. In WWE, they can.

That was not done on Sunday night.