Saturday night’s game against the Pittsburgh Pirates started out looking like a dream for the Cincinnati Reds and their fans. It ended looking like a dream of a completely different kind, a complete nightmare.
While the Reds are in a precarious position, they are still alive in the race for a playoff spot. Cincinnati will need help over the season’s final days to reach the playoffs but most importantly, the Reds need to win. So, when Cincinnati jumped out to a 9-0 lead after three innings, it appeared as though the Reds would at least hold up their end of the bargain. Appearances can be deceiving.
The Pirates chipped away at the deficit, scoring once in the fourth inning and five times in the sixth, trimming the deficit to 9-6. Then, after Pittsburgh then loaded the bases with nobody out in the seventh inning, Pirates first baseman Alfonso Rivas smacked a line drive into the right field corner. Jack Suwinski and Jared Triolo scored on the play and when Cincinnati’s Stuart Fairchild couldn’t stop the ball, Endy Rodríguez sprinted home with the tying run.
"YOU GOTTA BE KIDDING ME. THEY'RE GONNA BOO THE REDS OUT OF CINCINNATI. HOW 'BOUT THESE BATTLING BUCS."
The Reds once led this game 9-0. pic.twitter.com/QYgyxVBrfR
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) September 24, 2023
As unmistakable (and understandable) as the frustration from the fans at the Great American Ballpark was then, it only got worse.
Suwinski and Rivas both delivered RBI hits in the top of the eighth inning to put the Pirates ahead 11-9. Ji-hwan Bae then drove in two more runs with a double to give Pittsburgh a 13-9 lead.
"WHAT A GREAT NIGHT TO BE A PIRATE. PITTSBURGH, REJOICE…THE PIRATES ARE GOOD AGAIN." pic.twitter.com/t1F8FwUn3d
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) September 24, 2023
If the Pirates had gone on to win 13-9, it would have been a frustrating, inexcusable loss for the Reds. Somehow, though, it only got worse.
Cincinnati scored a pair of runs in the bottom of the eighth inning, cutting the deficit to 13-11. Then, Joey Votto singled and TJ Friedl doubled to start the bottom of the ninth inning, giving the Reds the tying run on second base with nobody out. Jake Fraley made an out, but a highly productive one, as his groundout scored Votto and moved Friedl over to third. That brought Elly De La Cruz to the plate, needing only a fly ball to the outfield to tie the game. It never happened.
De La Cruz got into a fierce battle against Pittsburgh closer, Carmen Mlodzinski, working a 3-2 count and then fouling four pitches off. But on the 11th pitch of the at-bat, De La Cruz swung through an inside sweeper from Mlodzinski, striking out and leaving it up to Jonathan India. India fell behind 1-2, then on the fourth pitch of the at-bat, hit a flyball to center field. Suwinski made the easy putout, giving the Pirates a 13-12 win.
With the tying run on third and one out, Pirates pitcher Carmen Mlodzinski strikes Elly De La Cruz out. He then gets Jonathan India on a flyout to CF, ending the game.
The Reds led 9-0 at one point pic.twitter.com/wgk9a06viI
— The Comeback (@thecomeback) September 24, 2023
There are two sides to every game like this. The Pirates, who are effectively out of the playoff race but taking their role as spoilers to heart, were understandably elated.
"THE PIRATES WITH THEIR BEST COME-FROM-BEHIND WIN EVER. THEY WERE DOWN 9 IN CINCINNATI AND THEY HAVE BEATEN THE REDS, STUNNING CINCINNATI AND DASHING THEIR PLAYOFF DREAMS." https://t.co/ii7rKxiqeH
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) September 24, 2023
But for the Reds, this was a brutal loss. And there was no sugarcoating it.
"A heartbreaking gut-punch day. The Reds led by 9, they fall by 1, a 13-12 day of misery for Cincinnati." pic.twitter.com/hKQyg3CDgw
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) September 24, 2023
It was 9-0, Reds! IT WAS 9-0!!!! pic.twitter.com/2rkTRV7SF4
— Schlasser (@UrinatingTree) September 24, 2023
After this shit they deserve to be booed out of Cincinnati https://t.co/r81N4wiGPm
— ♠️♠️♠️ (@jcc__13) September 24, 2023
Disaster for the Reds. Alexis Díaz, the team's best pitcher, allows four runs in the eighth inning in the biggest game of the year.
The Pirates lead 13-9 in an unforgetable meltdown.
— Charlie Goldsmith (@CharlieG__) September 24, 2023